[ { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.36363636363636365", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "22", "TotalMoves-2nd": "13", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-095718", "UUID": "019035ef-61e9-7d53-be2d-152d8ef191ae" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4642857142857143", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "28", "TotalMoves-2nd": "14", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-095808", "UUID": "019035ef-fcf0-7348-8976-4b214c438ccd" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.42857142857142855", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "28", "TotalMoves-2nd": "16", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-095853", "UUID": "019035f0-be2f-7802-a73d-554a0952294f" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4074074074074074", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "27", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-095932", "UUID": "019035f1-6de6-7f98-8624-9bcf0a6b7b12" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.15", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "14", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-100016", "UUID": "019035f2-080d-784f-82c2-4c6fea2c8bd2" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.47058823529411764", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "34", "TotalMoves-2nd": "16", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-100100", "UUID": "019035f2-b4f5-7b98-ae8d-063c363c835d" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3333333333333333", "TotalMoves-1st": "17", "TotalMoves-2nd": "18", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-070049", "UUID": "0190354d-b7c1-7001-ba90-de2b3af250d2" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2857142857142857", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5555555555555556", "TotalMoves-1st": "21", "TotalMoves-2nd": "27", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-070215", "UUID": "0190354e-69fc-7e7f-9209-35b3671e4a05" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5217391304347826", "TotalMoves-1st": "16", "TotalMoves-2nd": "23", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-070305", "UUID": "0190354f-b86c-78ae-b7b2-6c184bd3aa98" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "1", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4482758620689655", "TotalMoves-1st": "19", "TotalMoves-2nd": "29", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-070351", "UUID": "01903550-7ce1-70b7-b922-ae4284a2f9ec" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "3", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5416666666666666", "TotalMoves-1st": "16", "TotalMoves-2nd": "24", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-070436", "UUID": "01903551-2f66-7f8e-b9b4-22ebaa9c8955" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.16666666666666666", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.37037037037037035", "TotalMoves-1st": "24", "TotalMoves-2nd": "27", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-070531", "UUID": "01903551-ddce-7a04-856f-44078e560a44" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.15384615384615385", "TotalMoves-1st": "15", "TotalMoves-2nd": "13", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-103653", "UUID": "019026a0-448e-7f72-bdf1-6590db946e44" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "18", "TotalMoves-2nd": "13", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-103749", "UUID": "019026a1-2499-718c-bb0a-483434b721c8" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "15", "TotalMoves-2nd": "14", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-103842", "UUID": "019026a1-ffe1-7d63-8f0b-c95983fd01cc" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "17", "TotalMoves-2nd": "13", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-103934", "UUID": "019026a2-cfa3-77f6-83c2-62ed3b0963cb" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "16", "TotalMoves-2nd": "11", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-104025", "UUID": "019026a3-9baf-7531-963b-5cee8845ee47" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "1", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "5", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.1", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "18", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-104133", "UUID": "019026a4-6284-7505-aab7-1c98d3e7e351" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.043478260869565216", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "23", "TotalMoves-2nd": "17", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-104251", "UUID": "019026a5-6cf8-76c0-b779-7df68b4e3b9c" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "16", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-104353", "UUID": "019026a6-9a34-7f06-883b-482005c06491" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.047619047619047616", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "21", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-104504", "UUID": "019026a7-8e37-756d-88e1-4b6f9c575c81" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "2", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2962962962962963", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "27", "TotalMoves-2nd": "16", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-104631", "UUID": "019026a8-a35f-726a-bfce-fdb8e0216c7a" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "1", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "23", "TotalMoves-2nd": "18", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-104734", "UUID": "019026a9-f62f-7289-a3a0-45f985f4d68b" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.23529411764705882", "TotalMoves-1st": "17", "TotalMoves-2nd": "17", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-104841", "UUID": "019026aa-ef29-792c-ab2c-11931df0fdd5" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "15", "TotalMoves-2nd": "10", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-104931", "UUID": "019026ab-f296-76a0-9727-c36a212237b5" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "16", "TotalMoves-2nd": "12", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-105027", "UUID": "019026ac-b5b3-7372-b783-5f32d3efedb6" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "18", "TotalMoves-2nd": "14", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-105125", "UUID": "019026ad-8f88-72c3-bf98-44f3ef6c839a" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "19", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-105223", "UUID": "019026ae-734b-7ae7-b8fb-8f80ae7c9c6f" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.25", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-105338", "UUID": "019026af-55f2-782d-8fc3-12858845f4af" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "15", "TotalMoves-2nd": "10", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-105426", "UUID": "019026b0-7b4f-7986-bf59-bd3897e0553b" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "5", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "25", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-105529", "UUID": "019026b1-3555-7d5c-9126-4573291d9800" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "17", "TotalMoves-2nd": "14", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-105622", "UUID": "019026b2-2c2d-70ed-b7c4-ddaa3803a1b6" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "18", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-105713", "UUID": "019026b2-fc8c-7052-a502-ffa0e8ea4616" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "15", "TotalMoves-2nd": "10", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-105806", "UUID": "019026b3-c299-70a4-a493-446a14ee139e" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "17", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-105904", "UUID": "019026b4-9262-7ea2-98eb-2ae4e71cc5ca" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "19", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-110003", "UUID": "019026b5-75d5-7a21-82e5-5db2547f4a45" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "1", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-110103", "UUID": "019026b6-5bc8-7dea-853e-5485a5cf8202" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "3", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "21", "TotalMoves-2nd": "16", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-110210", "UUID": "019026b7-4575-7303-9c19-e9087f66c911" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "1", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.05", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.1111111111111111", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "18", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-110329", "UUID": "019026b8-4c36-72d5-be3f-7da693bb00b6" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "1", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "19", "TotalMoves-2nd": "16", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-110434", "UUID": "019026b9-819f-7383-bce3-7fcb7ed965a7" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "21", "TotalMoves-2nd": "18", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-110538", "UUID": "019026ba-7e72-7701-8ccf-d31ea52303a8" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "1", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "23", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240617-110645", "UUID": "019026bb-760a-7bd4-a210-4abcbac251e8" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-222347", "UUID": "0190525a-899f-7a92-a47b-b956f24706bc" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.15", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.07692307692307693", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "13", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-222427", "UUID": "0190525b-360b-7156-a349-481271712d59" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.058823529411764705", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "17", "TotalMoves-2nd": "11", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-222502", "UUID": "0190525b-d057-7fd8-b52f-4863a6eae13a" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "15", "TotalMoves-2nd": "10", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-222529", "UUID": "0190525c-59e6-71a7-b23b-4579246e8807" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "2", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "21", "TotalMoves-2nd": "16", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-222609", "UUID": "0190525c-c3fe-7a7e-8fd8-c692c4b26294" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "17", "TotalMoves-2nd": "13", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-222644", "UUID": "0190525d-5f85-7006-81aa-cf2ed8788fd9" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.19047619047619047", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.35", "TotalMoves-1st": "21", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-222709", "UUID": "0190525d-e83e-7fcf-8963-0e8f2013a6ee" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.05555555555555555", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "18", "TotalMoves-2nd": "14", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-222741", "UUID": "0190525e-4c2d-711d-9219-f21634920f97" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "1", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.18518518518518517", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "27", "TotalMoves-2nd": "18", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-222834", "UUID": "0190525e-c842-79b0-bd63-3e1533c7fd56" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "3", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "23", "TotalMoves-2nd": "18", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-222921", "UUID": "0190525f-9652-7ce5-8cd5-add742b8fdae" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "17", "TotalMoves-2nd": "12", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-222953", "UUID": "01905260-4f84-75ca-b38d-5bda2f0aa096" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-223028", "UUID": "01905260-cb68-740c-9142-9ef3d4e728cb" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "19", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-223110", "UUID": "01905261-5245-7644-aca0-e15a8d40847a" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4074074074074074", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "27", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-223132", "UUID": "01905261-f791-7c6c-904f-a82ef7ae7a5b" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5135135135135135", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.18181818181818182", "TotalMoves-1st": "37", "TotalMoves-2nd": "22", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-100839", "UUID": "019035f9-614c-748e-b881-9b55ffbd0561" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "3", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3076923076923077", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5", "TotalMoves-1st": "26", "TotalMoves-2nd": "26", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-101001", "UUID": "019035fa-5f9c-7637-a61b-5b6030761232" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.46153846153846156", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.07142857142857142", "TotalMoves-1st": "26", "TotalMoves-2nd": "14", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-101051", "UUID": "019035fb-9f86-7090-861c-f52cb7609e3c" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4074074074074074", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.25", "TotalMoves-1st": "27", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-101143", "UUID": "019035fc-6320-702b-9ca3-33d65ad5bcdc" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4666666666666667", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3333333333333333", "TotalMoves-1st": "30", "TotalMoves-2nd": "21", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-101246", "UUID": "019035fd-2f43-743f-a8ea-0cc8b591e2db" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.15", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "24", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-071428", "UUID": "01903559-ea8c-7e87-a91c-214b71ddea10" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3181818181818182", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3888888888888889", "TotalMoves-1st": "22", "TotalMoves-2nd": "18", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-071545", "UUID": "0190355a-e87b-7a7d-a7a0-b97c11b4df1b" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.34615384615384615", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.44", "TotalMoves-1st": "26", "TotalMoves-2nd": "25", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-071654", "UUID": "0190355c-15c9-7f64-b059-6a60f094b9cf" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "3", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.125", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4838709677419355", "TotalMoves-1st": "24", "TotalMoves-2nd": "31", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-071754", "UUID": "0190355d-22e0-76d8-8045-e363ea5f7e65" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.22727272727272727", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5", "TotalMoves-1st": "22", "TotalMoves-2nd": "24", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-071856", "UUID": "0190355e-0d97-7882-a72d-bbe5b4add230" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.21052631578947367", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.35", "TotalMoves-1st": "19", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-104412", "UUID": "0190120c-9205-7e08-a9f4-d9b0eb37e101" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "3", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.25", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.48", "TotalMoves-1st": "24", "TotalMoves-2nd": "25", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-104610", "UUID": "0190120e-69b6-7d04-9dd0-289393544bcc" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.38461538461538464", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.07142857142857142", "TotalMoves-1st": "26", "TotalMoves-2nd": "14", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-104752", "UUID": "01901210-345e-7ab5-aaa9-c7c95faa9b0f" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.05555555555555555", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.14285714285714285", "TotalMoves-1st": "18", "TotalMoves-2nd": "14", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-104929", "UUID": "01901211-c2eb-7250-a767-5da7f09a0423" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5172413793103449", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.1875", "TotalMoves-1st": "29", "TotalMoves-2nd": "16", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-105146", "UUID": "01901213-3d12-749b-a793-025039afee0f" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "3", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.36363636363636365", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5454545454545454", "TotalMoves-1st": "22", "TotalMoves-2nd": "22", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-105336", "UUID": "01901215-56e4-79cb-a5bc-fc4153cb88f4" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.0625", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.2857142857142857", "TotalMoves-1st": "16", "TotalMoves-2nd": "14", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-105455", "UUID": "01901217-018c-7b4e-b870-295fb1ad9578" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.16666666666666666", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.09090909090909091", "TotalMoves-1st": "18", "TotalMoves-2nd": "11", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-105621", "UUID": "01901218-38c0-7c09-b4e8-e72473ce83e5" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4722222222222222", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.13636363636363635", "TotalMoves-1st": "36", "TotalMoves-2nd": "22", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-105837", "UUID": "01901219-88af-7ed0-bd03-837a5f3ad62b" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.05", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.375", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "24", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-110036", "UUID": "0190121b-9ccb-7044-99cc-ccf07374f656" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "5", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5714285714285714", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.0625", "TotalMoves-1st": "35", "TotalMoves-2nd": "16", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-110221", "UUID": "0190121d-6aac-7f3d-846c-cdfe13bb0647" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.22727272727272727", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4", "TotalMoves-1st": "22", "TotalMoves-2nd": "25", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-110403", "UUID": "0190121f-0756-73a1-9c60-3f6a805e55b7" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.38461538461538464", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "26", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-110602", "UUID": "01901220-965d-7269-99c4-6147085b16c6" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "3", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.21739130434782608", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.48148148148148145", "TotalMoves-1st": "23", "TotalMoves-2nd": "27", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-110800", "UUID": "01901222-64c0-79c3-a829-b7f9d19e9130" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5161290322580645", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "31", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-110957", "UUID": "01901224-342f-7ca3-864d-7ad84ce8b693" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2916666666666667", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5357142857142857", "TotalMoves-1st": "24", "TotalMoves-2nd": "28", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-111140", "UUID": "01901225-fa82-7e6a-b584-0a6fcebe1d19" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5294117647058824", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3181818181818182", "TotalMoves-1st": "34", "TotalMoves-2nd": "22", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-111357", "UUID": "01901227-8da4-723a-b71d-bd48b7b94695" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2727272727272727", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.16666666666666666", "TotalMoves-1st": "22", "TotalMoves-2nd": "18", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-111539", "UUID": "01901229-a666-71e7-a776-ffe211c32d79" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.25", "TotalMoves-1st": "30", "TotalMoves-2nd": "16", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-111715", "UUID": "0190122b-34f9-7297-aebb-f517ad2f9dc2" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4482758620689655", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.17647058823529413", "TotalMoves-1st": "29", "TotalMoves-2nd": "17", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-111846", "UUID": "0190122c-a90b-7a35-af50-a14a05d0c044" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.22727272727272727", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.17647058823529413", "TotalMoves-1st": "22", "TotalMoves-2nd": "17", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-224051", "UUID": "01905269-f6ba-74e5-a769-83cab7585757" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.10526315789473684", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.06666666666666667", "TotalMoves-1st": "19", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-224142", "UUID": "0190526a-d5ee-7256-a65f-68f8a29399a9" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.058823529411764705", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5", "TotalMoves-1st": "17", "TotalMoves-2nd": "26", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-224235", "UUID": "0190526b-9daa-73bf-8bed-779361100b2e" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.125", "TotalMoves-1st": "15", "TotalMoves-2nd": "16", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-224310", "UUID": "0190526c-6ab8-757c-8778-574d35bb2cc8" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "3", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.13043478260869565", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4827586206896552", "TotalMoves-1st": "23", "TotalMoves-2nd": "29", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-224413", "UUID": "0190526c-f31d-7c70-b619-442676d078b0" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4", "TotalMoves-1st": "17", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-224436", "UUID": "0190526d-e9f7-7ee6-a835-a31d64df52e8" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.34782608695652173", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.2777777777777778", "TotalMoves-1st": "23", "TotalMoves-2nd": "18", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-224531", "UUID": "0190526e-449c-7818-a6f6-85770c0a5d83" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4583333333333333", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "24", "TotalMoves-2nd": "10", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-224628", "UUID": "0190526f-19f0-7e0a-bb60-df965409c1eb" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3333333333333333", "TotalMoves-1st": "19", "TotalMoves-2nd": "24", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-224722", "UUID": "0190526f-fa4c-7358-9c95-0ad5d56e072d" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.23076923076923078", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.38461538461538464", "TotalMoves-1st": "26", "TotalMoves-2nd": "26", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-224820", "UUID": "01905270-cd87-7799-98f9-74623d767ca6" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.48148148148148145", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.29411764705882354", "TotalMoves-1st": "27", "TotalMoves-2nd": "17", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-224911", "UUID": "01905271-afab-7185-bcc0-27bd4830ffe1" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.32", "TotalMoves-1st": "36", "TotalMoves-2nd": "25", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-224945", "UUID": "01905272-77d3-7065-870d-3fac51d87471" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.23809523809523808", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "21", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-100230", "UUID": "019035f4-0faf-7cec-9b3d-dc8e64e00d10" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.35", "TotalMoves-1st": "28", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-100348", "UUID": "019035f4-be11-73f0-9a45-03489b41c03f" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.41379310344827586", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.15789473684210525", "TotalMoves-1st": "29", "TotalMoves-2nd": "19", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-100436", "UUID": "019035f5-ede7-7a34-a312-0157cc2d8a39" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.41379310344827586", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.34782608695652173", "TotalMoves-1st": "29", "TotalMoves-2nd": "23", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-100520", "UUID": "019035f6-acf1-7b15-9dfe-df0e8c2b768b" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4230769230769231", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "26", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-100603", "UUID": "019035f7-57ae-7e3f-8c20-8983f668fb00" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.46875", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.0625", "TotalMoves-1st": "32", "TotalMoves-2nd": "16", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-100648", "UUID": "019035f7-fdd7-704a-89f1-f29bcfa812a8" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5555555555555556", "TotalMoves-1st": "17", "TotalMoves-2nd": "27", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-070650", "UUID": "01903553-4811-705a-8bb5-fd756ed1e4fd" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.1", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.43478260869565216", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "23", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-070742", "UUID": "01903553-ebfe-7103-96a0-55516cad2fb5" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4583333333333333", "TotalMoves-1st": "18", "TotalMoves-2nd": "24", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-070831", "UUID": "01903554-b771-7dc9-b6e4-e2775a987337" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.21739130434782608", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.375", "TotalMoves-1st": "23", "TotalMoves-2nd": "24", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-070918", "UUID": "01903555-747e-7359-85d0-f1c6e8217309" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.44", "TotalMoves-1st": "19", "TotalMoves-2nd": "25", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-071006", "UUID": "01903556-2d29-7335-89bb-32c3e9a84cb8" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "1", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4838709677419355", "TotalMoves-1st": "19", "TotalMoves-2nd": "31", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-071056", "UUID": "01903556-ea8c-7153-ad53-2e14809b82d9" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.2222222222222222", "TotalMoves-1st": "17", "TotalMoves-2nd": "18", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-235743", "UUID": "019014e3-d95c-7c7a-b217-ce0db23bfcb4" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "18", "TotalMoves-2nd": "14", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-235843", "UUID": "019014e4-e4d7-7912-9f9a-97b03496070f" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4090909090909091", "TotalMoves-1st": "18", "TotalMoves-2nd": "22", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-235944", "UUID": "019014e5-cece-7b31-b39b-ef4c5056474f" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "1", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.07142857142857142", "TotalMoves-1st": "17", "TotalMoves-2nd": "14", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-000042", "UUID": "019014e6-bdca-7828-9b0a-09b09e2e3db9" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.11764705882352941", "TotalMoves-1st": "18", "TotalMoves-2nd": "17", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-000145", "UUID": "019014e7-9f33-7b69-b722-d577b76dbf35" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.17391304347826086", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "23", "TotalMoves-2nd": "17", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-000307", "UUID": "019014e8-944e-7de0-873e-7f4c9c95843a" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.28", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "25", "TotalMoves-2nd": "17", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-000437", "UUID": "019014e9-d6b5-73d4-8c92-b6402ddcc8f7" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "1", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.18181818181818182", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4583333333333333", "TotalMoves-1st": "22", "TotalMoves-2nd": "24", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-000603", "UUID": "019014eb-34bd-7dee-9b42-04a05f802aa2" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "1", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "5", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.16666666666666666", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "18", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-000716", "UUID": "019014ec-86ee-7bcd-b5d7-71f535ce975a" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.1", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.06666666666666667", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-000828", "UUID": "019014ed-a285-70d8-a3d7-53a3371f8ed2" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "16", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-000929", "UUID": "019014ee-ba8f-7b38-85c6-5e96a73fa456" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.047619047619047616", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.25", "TotalMoves-1st": "21", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-001048", "UUID": "019014ef-a97b-7137-93f6-c391db7099ca" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "3", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.22580645161290322", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.05", "TotalMoves-1st": "31", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-001211", "UUID": "019014f0-e0af-7d8c-be7d-aa4154fbd32d" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "1", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "5", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.05", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "19", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-001322", "UUID": "019014f2-237d-77db-9ad2-951ef1f02acd" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "1", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.08695652173913043", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "23", "TotalMoves-2nd": "19", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-001438", "UUID": "019014f3-36ef-7660-aa07-6ea6e17d06ca" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.1111111111111111", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "18", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-001540", "UUID": "019014f4-6174-7974-8808-4b2ae8e74e82" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.20833333333333334", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.21739130434782608", "TotalMoves-1st": "24", "TotalMoves-2nd": "23", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-001703", "UUID": "019014f5-541d-7fa7-b71a-21b8b5b0bdc9" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2222222222222222", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.05263157894736842", "TotalMoves-1st": "27", "TotalMoves-2nd": "19", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-001820", "UUID": "019014f6-96c6-7285-82e4-bc0420d005fc" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "1", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "5", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-001927", "UUID": "019014f7-c4d8-76aa-930b-d16b866c539a" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.41379310344827586", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.058823529411764705", "TotalMoves-1st": "29", "TotalMoves-2nd": "17", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-002041", "UUID": "019014f8-c8b8-79e4-ae2c-99072a6146d3" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "1", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.08333333333333333", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.05263157894736842", "TotalMoves-1st": "24", "TotalMoves-2nd": "19", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-002147", "UUID": "019014f9-eb8b-752b-8e20-191c548e4f0a" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.30434782608695654", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "23", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-002306", "UUID": "019014fa-eed7-7189-aa2c-26ba528ec957" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "1", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "5", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-002418", "UUID": "019014fc-23ae-7241-a376-5c0206306a09" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "2", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.2", "TotalMoves-1st": "21", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-002526", "UUID": "019014fd-3d21-7353-a246-64a9e42655ad" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.058823529411764705", "TotalMoves-1st": "19", "TotalMoves-2nd": "17", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-002630", "UUID": "019014fe-4659-7bf5-8015-d177f3d58588" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.19047619047619047", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "21", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-002736", "UUID": "019014ff-3f1d-7f54-9de0-a0018655d7fc" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "1", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.34782608695652173", "TotalMoves-1st": "18", "TotalMoves-2nd": "23", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-002857", "UUID": "01901500-427e-7cb0-bb03-21db7c799803" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "21", "TotalMoves-2nd": "18", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-063923", "UUID": "01901501-7bef-72ff-9758-7d243fc4f570" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2857142857142857", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.32", "TotalMoves-1st": "28", "TotalMoves-2nd": "25", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-064046", "UUID": "01901654-9fee-7304-87aa-d674e81ba1ba" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "1", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "5", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "15", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-064149", "UUID": "01901655-e53b-7e66-af52-5eb5f89d777f" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "18", "TotalMoves-2nd": "16", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-223603", "UUID": "01905265-e1bd-7f0f-918b-2a41bd779e37" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.09090909090909091", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.058823529411764705", "TotalMoves-1st": "22", "TotalMoves-2nd": "17", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-223650", "UUID": "01905266-7095-73fd-b6c6-a53125c4f047" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "1", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "21", "TotalMoves-2nd": "17", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-223734", "UUID": "01905267-28ca-7fd1-a0d3-8e053007d79e" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "1", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "5", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.18181818181818182", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "22", "TotalMoves-2nd": "18", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-223812", "UUID": "01905267-d2c0-7f35-a946-37a107b240cc" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "18", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-223851", "UUID": "01905268-6926-7ad7-812b-f65cbacce2da" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.13043478260869565", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "23", "TotalMoves-2nd": "18", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-223936", "UUID": "01905268-fe7e-7ae4-b6df-bfb53937e596" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.375", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "24", "TotalMoves-2nd": "13", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-223954", "UUID": "01905269-aff4-7ecb-b6ea-78daaad4f031" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "1", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.07692307692307693", "TotalMoves-1st": "17", "TotalMoves-2nd": "13", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-223205", "UUID": "01905262-4c61-74c5-abfa-dd8e8d1b8d40" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.0625", "TotalMoves-1st": "19", "TotalMoves-2nd": "16", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-223249", "UUID": "01905262-cddf-70d9-8790-8dde4a31d579" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "17", "TotalMoves-2nd": "12", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-223322", "UUID": "01905263-79e6-7b1d-8565-04aead83cc80" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.16666666666666666", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "18", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-223359", "UUID": "01905263-fb76-7c9d-ac00-924c882dc8c1" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "1", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.07142857142857142", "TotalMoves-1st": "18", "TotalMoves-2nd": "14", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-223431", "UUID": "01905264-8d1a-7d4b-9294-70b07eed28b9" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "16", "TotalMoves-2nd": "11", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-223502", "UUID": "01905265-09bd-7f96-a8ee-a9017aa1e469" }, { "GameType": "tic-tac-toe", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "1", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.391304347826087", "TotalMoves-1st": "19", "TotalMoves-2nd": "23", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-223527", "UUID": "01905265-82b3-7c9f-902a-a6455729e852" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.06976744186046512", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.417910447761194", "TotalMoves-1st": "86", "TotalMoves-2nd": "134", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-113250", "UUID": "01903642-c00e-7b9f-8fe9-1e3988e560ef" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.038461538461538464", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6198347107438017", "TotalMoves-1st": "52", "TotalMoves-2nd": "121", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-113758", "UUID": "01903647-733a-7cfe-a1ce-12a780a5981c" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.027777777777777776", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4297520661157025", "TotalMoves-1st": "72", "TotalMoves-2nd": "121", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-114151", "UUID": "0190364c-2799-77aa-b325-428f1c65561e" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.02040816326530612", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.48314606741573035", "TotalMoves-1st": "49", "TotalMoves-2nd": "89", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-114417", "UUID": "0190364f-b27c-7b93-b097-9222668a5dad" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "1", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "5", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.07407407407407407", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.34782608695652173", "TotalMoves-1st": "81", "TotalMoves-2nd": "115", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-114817", "UUID": "01903651-ee6d-7322-890a-f3f50ca08569" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4144144144144144", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.06153846153846154", "TotalMoves-1st": "111", "TotalMoves-2nd": "65", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-093208", "UUID": "019035d4-d874-7fca-a602-1afc9cafc78d" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "5", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.6779661016949152", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "118", "TotalMoves-2nd": "38", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-093916", "UUID": "019035d8-f071-717f-b604-91df163665e2" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5034965034965035", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.02857142857142857", "TotalMoves-1st": "143", "TotalMoves-2nd": "70", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-094341", "UUID": "019035df-7aee-7d54-a32f-e2d6759af81b" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4789915966386555", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.06349206349206349", "TotalMoves-1st": "119", "TotalMoves-2nd": "63", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-094651", "UUID": "019035e3-82cf-70d8-8d5f-918e608c6069" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.36363636363636365", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.05714285714285714", "TotalMoves-1st": "110", "TotalMoves-2nd": "70", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-095020", "UUID": "019035e6-6ada-7285-937b-8b51921f2732" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5217391304347826", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.7184466019417476", "TotalMoves-1st": "69", "TotalMoves-2nd": "103", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-181025", "UUID": "019013a0-c45a-787c-b32b-44ebb28d3a5a" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "5", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.23809523809523808", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6504065040650406", "TotalMoves-1st": "63", "TotalMoves-2nd": "123", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-181635", "UUID": "019013a6-ecb0-723d-9787-91967c1a20d9" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.38666666666666666", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5656565656565656", "TotalMoves-1st": "75", "TotalMoves-2nd": "99", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-182151", "UUID": "019013ac-9482-7444-adf7-c4056655a91d" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4148148148148148", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.45", "TotalMoves-1st": "135", "TotalMoves-2nd": "140", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-202459", "UUID": "019013b1-64d1-73a1-a860-c7bf3629421d" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "5", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.7619047619047619", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4318181818181818", "TotalMoves-1st": "105", "TotalMoves-2nd": "44", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-203137", "UUID": "01901422-1fef-7620-b0ed-90864ec67996" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.6915887850467289", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6097560975609756", "TotalMoves-1st": "107", "TotalMoves-2nd": "82", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-203907", "UUID": "01901428-33a4-7837-a6e8-1eb614518e25" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "5", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.7547169811320755", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.44680851063829785", "TotalMoves-1st": "106", "TotalMoves-2nd": "47", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-204505", "UUID": "0190142f-10d6-7753-8e3d-53e288825c53" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "5", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.7843137254901961", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.2903225806451613", "TotalMoves-1st": "102", "TotalMoves-2nd": "31", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-205109", "UUID": "01901434-8976-70df-a89a-324f54a8f692" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "5", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.6956521739130435", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.36363636363636365", "TotalMoves-1st": "115", "TotalMoves-2nd": "55", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-205634", "UUID": "0190143a-1631-7295-8a8c-9dd1f44fb9d4" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.7111111111111111", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.7", "TotalMoves-1st": "90", "TotalMoves-2nd": "80", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-210246", "UUID": "0190143f-0d62-7dde-bcfb-6908e773add9" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "5", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.7272727272727273", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5238095238095238", "TotalMoves-1st": "110", "TotalMoves-2nd": "63", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-210731", "UUID": "01901444-ba04-7961-a17f-6a4b1e984246" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5714285714285714", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4583333333333333", "TotalMoves-1st": "114", "TotalMoves-2nd": "97", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-215004", "UUID": "01901449-1052-7b87-9199-2dfde333dd5c" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.6470588235294118", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4875", "TotalMoves-1st": "119", "TotalMoves-2nd": "80", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-215632", "UUID": "01901470-05e7-7760-b839-6582660fe3ce" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "5", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.46938775510204084", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.7920792079207921", "TotalMoves-1st": "49", "TotalMoves-2nd": "101", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-220243", "UUID": "01901475-f2ab-707c-a8f3-be5a448ff9d4" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "5", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.41304347826086957", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.7843137254901961", "TotalMoves-1st": "46", "TotalMoves-2nd": "102", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-232300", "UUID": "0190147b-9b53-75ef-87fc-6be0fb33c99a" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5818181818181818", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5222222222222223", "TotalMoves-1st": "110", "TotalMoves-2nd": "90", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-233057", "UUID": "019014c5-1dfe-72ef-9859-c2ee5681529b" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5652173913043478", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.24615384615384617", "TotalMoves-1st": "177", "TotalMoves-2nd": "97", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-233705", "UUID": "019014cc-6427-78b3-9f9b-45bec39ae4fe" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5671641791044776", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.7572815533980582", "TotalMoves-1st": "67", "TotalMoves-2nd": "103", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-234250", "UUID": "019014d1-fffd-752b-a3aa-9e311c3f0104" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.609375", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.7613636363636364", "TotalMoves-1st": "64", "TotalMoves-2nd": "88", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-234658", "UUID": "019014d7-4400-7a06-ad89-7cddd9b004bc" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "3", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5675675675675675", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6086956521739131", "TotalMoves-1st": "111", "TotalMoves-2nd": "115", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-235229", "UUID": "019014db-0bc8-7de4-8d6c-c821fe73b4d4" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "5", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5925925925925926", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.45544554455445546", "TotalMoves-1st": "135", "TotalMoves-2nd": "101", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-080218", "UUID": "01905467-a41a-7981-a6ee-fb7e6b28b5e9" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "5", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4375", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.7843137254901961", "TotalMoves-1st": "48", "TotalMoves-2nd": "102", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-080659", "UUID": "0190546c-dc82-7860-a148-b1c038d2d240" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4166666666666667", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6666666666666666", "TotalMoves-1st": "72", "TotalMoves-2nd": "111", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-081212", "UUID": "01905471-2589-7c17-a3c2-18e24127c468" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5339805825242718", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5714285714285714", "TotalMoves-1st": "103", "TotalMoves-2nd": "105", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-081622", "UUID": "01905475-eb3c-7ee3-a0d1-3b8923cf3d7b" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.6434782608695652", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5851063829787234", "TotalMoves-1st": "115", "TotalMoves-2nd": "94", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-082051", "UUID": "01905479-bc25-7aa3-a569-4d0bd374724e" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5895522388059702", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.01818181818181818", "TotalMoves-1st": "134", "TotalMoves-2nd": "55", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-082407", "UUID": "0190547d-d67e-7733-aa02-917755c5f1e8" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "5", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3582089552238806", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6779661016949152", "TotalMoves-1st": "67", "TotalMoves-2nd": "118", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-082846", "UUID": "01905480-d4f2-71e6-a7c4-0a995213528d" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.7475728155339806", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5535714285714286", "TotalMoves-1st": "103", "TotalMoves-2nd": "56", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-083353", "UUID": "01905485-163d-738c-9f6f-f653ff3e14ed" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "5", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.8080808080808081", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.525", "TotalMoves-1st": "99", "TotalMoves-2nd": "40", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-083819", "UUID": "01905489-c570-7fa8-8bc6-4f4af3bd3810" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "3", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5416666666666666", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6371681415929203", "TotalMoves-1st": "96", "TotalMoves-2nd": "113", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-092921", "UUID": "0190548d-d441-78dd-9674-1768beebdfeb" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "3", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.6788990825688074", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6804123711340206", "TotalMoves-1st": "109", "TotalMoves-2nd": "97", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-093446", "UUID": "019054bc-8e8b-74f7-8251-bc2772374296" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.0625", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5692307692307692", "TotalMoves-1st": "64", "TotalMoves-2nd": "130", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-093900", "UUID": "019054c1-8267-755c-aa55-35333ee496c8" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.10091743119266056", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4110429447852761", "TotalMoves-1st": "109", "TotalMoves-2nd": "163", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-111105", "UUID": "01903630-53ca-7b54-964f-1fb14fe675aa" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.8089887640449438", "TotalMoves-1st": "21", "TotalMoves-2nd": "89", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-111355", "UUID": "01903633-88c6-7937-aa65-64f5f74a7686" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.05714285714285714", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.7156862745098039", "TotalMoves-1st": "35", "TotalMoves-2nd": "102", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-111625", "UUID": "01903636-1f9e-70a2-a542-2fccc1eb788e" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.02631578947368421", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6826923076923077", "TotalMoves-1st": "38", "TotalMoves-2nd": "104", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-111842", "UUID": "01903638-6aee-7a29-ab3c-cfac6b96b883" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.017857142857142856", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6076923076923076", "TotalMoves-1st": "56", "TotalMoves-2nd": "130", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-112115", "UUID": "0190363a-81c8-7969-8e8e-03f09711bf41" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.16751269035532995", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.2767857142857143", "TotalMoves-1st": "197", "TotalMoves-2nd": "224", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-112656", "UUID": "0190363c-d62c-7f23-93bc-93bb8abee1bc" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.36363636363636365", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.03333333333333333", "TotalMoves-1st": "99", "TotalMoves-2nd": "60", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-083020", "UUID": "0190359e-8192-781c-a111-d90cd5b2cc19" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "45", "TotalMoves-2nd": "22", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-083142", "UUID": "019035a0-5c60-77bc-b990-83df094a0f04" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.6666666666666666", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "72", "TotalMoves-2nd": "21", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-083338", "UUID": "019035a1-9f69-720f-8f48-5b9a258daec2" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5733333333333334", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.03333333333333333", "TotalMoves-1st": "75", "TotalMoves-2nd": "30", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-083518", "UUID": "019035a3-63ea-7268-a487-20e06bc37897" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5887096774193549", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.02", "TotalMoves-1st": "124", "TotalMoves-2nd": "50", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-083740", "UUID": "019035a4-ea85-71dd-9a47-193c3d00d6a5" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.25", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.17272727272727273", "TotalMoves-1st": "128", "TotalMoves-2nd": "110", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-084050", "UUID": "019035a7-158c-74ae-b0ce-d5ff7846f104" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5230769230769231", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.7452830188679245", "TotalMoves-1st": "65", "TotalMoves-2nd": "106", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-153538", "UUID": "0190183b-d3a1-7c0d-a010-de8f9775d834" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "5", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.38235294117647056", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.8333333333333334", "TotalMoves-1st": "34", "TotalMoves-2nd": "96", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-153843", "UUID": "0190183f-94f0-764a-abce-714a43a0fd22" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.24324324324324326", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.75", "TotalMoves-1st": "37", "TotalMoves-2nd": "92", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-154131", "UUID": "01901842-66c9-738c-bc08-0e8de9164458" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.23809523809523808", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.7428571428571429", "TotalMoves-1st": "42", "TotalMoves-2nd": "105", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-154436", "UUID": "01901844-f7d9-76a5-9a4d-9b3f800c20d2" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.43119266055045874", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3626373626373626", "TotalMoves-1st": "109", "TotalMoves-2nd": "91", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-154902", "UUID": "01901847-ca1b-767b-84bb-fbdb94e309e3" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.7582417582417582", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5227272727272727", "TotalMoves-1st": "91", "TotalMoves-2nd": "44", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-155224", "UUID": "0190184b-da56-731b-be82-129ef473a858" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5675675675675675", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.8125", "TotalMoves-1st": "63", "TotalMoves-2nd": "87", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-155518", "UUID": "0190184e-ed56-7ed9-b5b5-5c1e9c8f116e" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2777777777777778", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.65625", "TotalMoves-1st": "36", "TotalMoves-2nd": "64", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-155741", "UUID": "01901851-9484-7b82-a2f2-0330e96e85c1" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.6031746031746031", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6037735849056604", "TotalMoves-1st": "63", "TotalMoves-2nd": "53", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-160030", "UUID": "01901853-c4cc-77d6-86c7-6a4e3564bc3f" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.7051282051282052", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.25925925925925924", "TotalMoves-1st": "78", "TotalMoves-2nd": "27", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-160329", "UUID": "01901856-58e7-7fb6-938d-3d70440517a7" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.7297297297297297", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3076923076923077", "TotalMoves-1st": "90", "TotalMoves-2nd": "42", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-163514", "UUID": "01901859-1591-7833-9ead-1d7ac5b597ae" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "5", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.8080808080808081", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5581395348837209", "TotalMoves-1st": "99", "TotalMoves-2nd": "43", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-163853", "UUID": "01901876-274b-7959-a56f-89381d2991e9" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.7586206896551724", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6610169491525424", "TotalMoves-1st": "87", "TotalMoves-2nd": "59", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-164213", "UUID": "01901879-7c7b-7d51-a9ae-5a1387bffa0a" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5714285714285714", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.8571428571428571", "TotalMoves-1st": "35", "TotalMoves-2nd": "77", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-164449", "UUID": "0190187c-8946-70f0-b108-d78fd930afa4" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.7674418604651163", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.2692307692307692", "TotalMoves-1st": "86", "TotalMoves-2nd": "26", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-164745", "UUID": "0190187e-ecc0-7b38-a145-ea746950716a" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.6666666666666666", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4222222222222222", "TotalMoves-1st": "78", "TotalMoves-2nd": "45", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-165022", "UUID": "01901881-9a7d-7f33-b2a9-3b701b9d5156" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.7717391304347826", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5961538461538461", "TotalMoves-1st": "92", "TotalMoves-2nd": "52", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-165354", "UUID": "01901883-ff1c-743c-9921-5de8c3ab964b" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "5", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.11764705882352941", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.8888888888888888", "TotalMoves-1st": "17", "TotalMoves-2nd": "90", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-173344", "UUID": "01901887-3b91-7b89-89d7-4d7a3c8c11e7" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5263157894736842", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.825", "TotalMoves-1st": "38", "TotalMoves-2nd": "80", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-173620", "UUID": "019018ab-b5c8-762a-8704-45aa5722070a" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "5", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.7547169811320755", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.2972972972972973", "TotalMoves-1st": "106", "TotalMoves-2nd": "37", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-173924", "UUID": "019018ae-159e-701b-bd6a-405673517673" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5686274509803921", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.44594594594594594", "TotalMoves-1st": "102", "TotalMoves-2nd": "74", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-174251", "UUID": "019018b0-e554-7fa4-8f5d-077f9b9de45f" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.56", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.627906976744186", "TotalMoves-1st": "75", "TotalMoves-2nd": "86", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-174640", "UUID": "019018b4-0b8e-7f26-91ff-e9675fb98e8b" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.6388888888888888", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.7659574468085106", "TotalMoves-1st": "72", "TotalMoves-2nd": "94", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-175017", "UUID": "019018b7-8c3a-702f-a3ff-b81e65fb2fdd" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.48", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.7608695652173914", "TotalMoves-1st": "50", "TotalMoves-2nd": "92", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-175318", "UUID": "019018ba-dbb6-7419-bdc1-5d8fe69a9820" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5263157894736842", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.22727272727272727", "TotalMoves-1st": "114", "TotalMoves-2nd": "66", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-175657", "UUID": "019018bd-9ff8-74ea-b0b8-cf7e65e9ac74" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3333333333333333", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4722222222222222", "TotalMoves-1st": "90", "TotalMoves-2nd": "108", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-180100", "UUID": "019018c0-f5a6-733a-903d-4f5df3f7b2b9" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.37037037037037035", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.7142857142857143", "TotalMoves-1st": "54", "TotalMoves-2nd": "105", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-180443", "UUID": "019018c4-ac8a-7ad5-bea7-17e0df85a5d9" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.358974358974359", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.7558139534883721", "TotalMoves-1st": "39", "TotalMoves-2nd": "86", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-180743", "UUID": "019018c8-1447-7b61-bb69-0c18f14b3469" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.46551724137931033", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.7352941176470589", "TotalMoves-1st": "58", "TotalMoves-2nd": "102", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-181053", "UUID": "019018ca-d002-7d9d-bbf3-d452c4c8dbb5" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "3", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2857142857142857", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6593406593406593", "TotalMoves-1st": "78", "TotalMoves-2nd": "117", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-182758", "UUID": "019018cd-b709-7905-8e49-2c102d64b485" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "3", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5064935064935064", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.625", "TotalMoves-1st": "77", "TotalMoves-2nd": "88", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-071701", "UUID": "01905440-d4be-7518-b7e4-ddde985dcc72" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5964912280701754", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.7840909090909091", "TotalMoves-1st": "57", "TotalMoves-2nd": "88", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-072058", "UUID": "01905443-63ca-7e87-a341-0776a0490db2" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5769230769230769", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.7906976744186046", "TotalMoves-1st": "52", "TotalMoves-2nd": "86", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-072422", "UUID": "01905447-053d-7ab8-8038-1092849b2ca1" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "5", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2702702702702703", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.7843137254901961", "TotalMoves-1st": "37", "TotalMoves-2nd": "102", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-072649", "UUID": "0190544a-20a3-7aa7-bf09-5acdbc308d57" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "5", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2727272727272727", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.8080808080808081", "TotalMoves-1st": "33", "TotalMoves-2nd": "99", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-072857", "UUID": "0190544c-5f48-7f19-9b06-5775158b7063" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.46987951807228917", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.40298507462686567", "TotalMoves-1st": "83", "TotalMoves-2nd": "67", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-073208", "UUID": "0190544e-5139-7de7-b437-dcf6f0765570" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5844155844155844", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "77", "TotalMoves-2nd": "29", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-073412", "UUID": "01905451-3d3f-7440-879e-5986de92e651" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5826086956521739", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.47126436781609193", "TotalMoves-1st": "115", "TotalMoves-2nd": "87", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-073747", "UUID": "01905453-227d-79a9-b8cd-63fb82df6088" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "5", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.8", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6226415094339622", "TotalMoves-1st": "100", "TotalMoves-2nd": "53", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-074050", "UUID": "01905456-6949-737c-9cab-eb8057bd16c7" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5833333333333334", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.8674698795180723", "TotalMoves-1st": "36", "TotalMoves-2nd": "83", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-074301", "UUID": "01905459-3331-7927-bac3-a8926191f689" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.6770833333333334", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.581081081081081", "TotalMoves-1st": "96", "TotalMoves-2nd": "74", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-074600", "UUID": "0190545b-31d8-7b73-b0ba-0ca85a6f155d" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.6481481481481481", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5365853658536586", "TotalMoves-1st": "108", "TotalMoves-2nd": "82", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-074907", "UUID": "0190545d-ee3d-7711-b1ab-0854eb4dec24" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3619047619047619", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5153846153846153", "TotalMoves-1st": "105", "TotalMoves-2nd": "130", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-075424", "UUID": "01905460-c9e0-77ef-ac21-c41b25b5ce73" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.023255813953488372", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6448598130841121", "TotalMoves-1st": "43", "TotalMoves-2nd": "107", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-075636", "UUID": "01905465-a0fe-7dd9-9da8-d582eb0ce11a" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "1", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "5", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.027777777777777776", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "36", "TotalMoves-2nd": "35", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-104950", "UUID": "0190361f-244e-7ca0-a717-2cd096b8528a" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.0625", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.46296296296296297", "TotalMoves-1st": "32", "TotalMoves-2nd": "54", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-105132", "UUID": "01903620-1641-72c9-9035-80330d1bd13d" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "1", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "5", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.025", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "40", "TotalMoves-2nd": "39", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-105247", "UUID": "01903621-a2f0-7d03-a0f2-857e607187aa" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "1", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "5", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "45", "TotalMoves-2nd": "45", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-110253", "UUID": "01903622-c70d-7fd5-8d4c-be2e914744dc" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "1", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "5", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.10810810810810811", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "111", "TotalMoves-2nd": "99", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-110508", "UUID": "0190362c-05ec-7173-9a5f-057dae23328e" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "1", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "5", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.043478260869565216", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.029411764705882353", "TotalMoves-1st": "69", "TotalMoves-2nd": "68", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-110720", "UUID": "0190362e-17a8-7318-92f8-047364745923" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.047619047619047616", "TotalMoves-1st": "25", "TotalMoves-2nd": "21", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-082149", "UUID": "01903597-cbf6-7ec6-8a4a-0ea662d8083d" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2708333333333333", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.0625", "TotalMoves-1st": "48", "TotalMoves-2nd": "32", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-082323", "UUID": "01903598-91ea-7f83-ad7e-f8a4fda4885e" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.05128205128205128", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.030303030303030304", "TotalMoves-1st": "39", "TotalMoves-2nd": "33", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-082437", "UUID": "01903599-ff71-7b96-8cf9-f55344d8b911" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.03125", "TotalMoves-1st": "36", "TotalMoves-2nd": "32", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-082534", "UUID": "0190359b-234e-7ac1-9fd2-c28749678f77" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.045454545454545456", "TotalMoves-1st": "26", "TotalMoves-2nd": "22", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-082628", "UUID": "0190359c-00b9-72ac-9720-8917d67cc6a3" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "35", "TotalMoves-2nd": "30", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-082736", "UUID": "0190359c-d254-7e3e-b30c-87e3968aa8c9" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.45652173913043476", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5102040816326531", "TotalMoves-1st": "92", "TotalMoves-2nd": "98", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-203734", "UUID": "01900f02-ef36-7685-8dfd-27ef7bd59e54" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.6666666666666666", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5161290322580645", "TotalMoves-1st": "96", "TotalMoves-2nd": "62", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-204108", "UUID": "01900f07-4953-7239-97e7-01273e04ad40" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.10714285714285714", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "28", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-204231", "UUID": "01900f0a-8eda-77f8-b0d9-9ad7c3bc3a6f" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2857142857142857", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "35", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-204406", "UUID": "01900f0b-d22c-7181-bfbb-6fbdbcb6b5ed" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5964912280701754", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "57", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-204600", "UUID": "01900f0d-45bb-7c07-a7f8-1469567f4953" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3225806451612903", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.463768115942029", "TotalMoves-1st": "62", "TotalMoves-2nd": "69", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-204929", "UUID": "01900f0f-01b2-7fae-ae71-93841c793cdb" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5822784810126582", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3673469387755102", "TotalMoves-1st": "79", "TotalMoves-2nd": "49", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-205307", "UUID": "01900f12-3533-70f8-b4df-66d6cf53cd53" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3055555555555556", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "36", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-205459", "UUID": "01900f15-8610-7280-8dc1-42941eacf876" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.21875", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "32", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-205644", "UUID": "01900f17-3b38-7fe4-a38e-078e92466b91" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.39285714285714285", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.04081632653061224", "TotalMoves-1st": "84", "TotalMoves-2nd": "49", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-210043", "UUID": "01900f18-d5de-726b-b9e6-43730c41b063" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2857142857142857", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6727272727272727", "TotalMoves-1st": "56", "TotalMoves-2nd": "110", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-210427", "UUID": "01900f1c-7d6d-747e-a938-a18fbdc2bd06" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.32", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.44642857142857145", "TotalMoves-1st": "50", "TotalMoves-2nd": "56", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-210735", "UUID": "01900f1f-e7f1-728a-9acf-4601212f7385" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "25", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-210905", "UUID": "01900f22-c75f-7bf7-a9b7-6da41ba65a8f" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "27", "TotalMoves-2nd": "22", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-211043", "UUID": "01900f24-23f0-76b3-9d38-443cf0a938d8" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.037037037037037035", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.04081632653061224", "TotalMoves-1st": "54", "TotalMoves-2nd": "49", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-211355", "UUID": "01900f25-a2f5-79ae-aa80-70c1142fa2f7" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.07407407407407407", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.013513513513513514", "TotalMoves-1st": "81", "TotalMoves-2nd": "74", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-211804", "UUID": "01900f28-90b0-79ae-983e-40ce209c7921" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.02666666666666667", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3269230769230769", "TotalMoves-1st": "75", "TotalMoves-2nd": "104", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-212300", "UUID": "01900f2c-5eac-7f81-9084-81c3821b5b4f" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "1", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "5", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.10638297872340426", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.023255813953488372", "TotalMoves-1st": "47", "TotalMoves-2nd": "43", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-212536", "UUID": "01900f30-e22f-739b-aeb8-da5521f56dc8" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "46", "TotalMoves-2nd": "44", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-212813", "UUID": "01900f33-42f2-779e-afc9-533d37f14be9" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "62", "TotalMoves-2nd": "59", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-213133", "UUID": "01900f35-aacf-730d-ad92-fde555623b24" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.016666666666666666", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.07936507936507936", "TotalMoves-1st": "60", "TotalMoves-2nd": "63", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-213445", "UUID": "01900f38-b7bd-7aec-a2c0-56a2f767e298" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.03571428571428571", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.22388059701492538", "TotalMoves-1st": "56", "TotalMoves-2nd": "67", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-213947", "UUID": "01900f3b-a3da-77a1-aa65-6aca95457165" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.024390243902439025", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "41", "TotalMoves-2nd": "38", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-214220", "UUID": "01900f40-3efa-75cc-80b1-1acfae0b2f44" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "43", "TotalMoves-2nd": "38", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-214435", "UUID": "01900f42-970a-7d28-b6d9-6697fda9699b" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.020833333333333332", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "48", "TotalMoves-2nd": "43", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-214706", "UUID": "01900f44-a597-7075-b252-fb861dfbc68a" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.029850746268656716", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.046875", "TotalMoves-1st": "67", "TotalMoves-2nd": "64", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-215042", "UUID": "01900f46-f3d9-7720-9dc0-9e66d6a4b2d3" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.07526881720430108", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.39097744360902253", "TotalMoves-1st": "93", "TotalMoves-2nd": "133", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-215725", "UUID": "01900f4a-3f19-716a-a71a-3feda6dc714d" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "29", "TotalMoves-2nd": "25", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-220939", "UUID": "01900f50-65ff-766a-87c1-ec7995f6ff04" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.041666666666666664", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "48", "TotalMoves-2nd": "42", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-221209", "UUID": "01900f5b-9766-7cc4-b9da-e5bc02fe7623" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.016129032258064516", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.017543859649122806", "TotalMoves-1st": "62", "TotalMoves-2nd": "57", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-221528", "UUID": "01900f5d-e1a8-7602-b525-cbf2f48873df" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.045454545454545456", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "44", "TotalMoves-2nd": "37", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-064703", "UUID": "019052b5-46c1-7121-9405-e36de6fbc811" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "25", "TotalMoves-2nd": "21", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-064843", "UUID": "01905427-f49e-7d67-89fe-5d3257b016c5" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.03333333333333333", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4", "TotalMoves-1st": "30", "TotalMoves-2nd": "40", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-065107", "UUID": "01905429-7e0e-7d14-960f-205ad95fe637" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "25", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-065235", "UUID": "0190542b-b00d-7b4e-b6b4-f42884dde85d" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.038461538461538464", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "26", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-065358", "UUID": "0190542d-0604-7acc-b159-ca895125accc" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.034482758620689655", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "29", "TotalMoves-2nd": "23", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-065543", "UUID": "0190542e-4b87-7c88-a92a-e9aa662fed87" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "26", "TotalMoves-2nd": "21", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-065626", "UUID": "0190542f-e5d3-7afd-998d-9be267819efb" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5454545454545454", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "88", "TotalMoves-2nd": "38", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-183858", "UUID": "019056b1-3603-742f-81ce-2baaadc2444e" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5294117647058824", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.02631578947368421", "TotalMoves-1st": "85", "TotalMoves-2nd": "38", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-184215", "UUID": "019056b3-bf8d-7aaa-bfff-a05f7bf1e24c" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4074074074074074", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "81", "TotalMoves-2nd": "45", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-184529", "UUID": "019056b6-bd64-7ee2-80a2-5f3301b8298c" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "53", "TotalMoves-2nd": "50", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-184817", "UUID": "019056b9-b5a1-7b1e-b038-bc2dc7043bfc" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "48", "TotalMoves-2nd": "44", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-185041", "UUID": "019056bc-4695-7d69-87e9-fabc61463c46" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.01639344262295082", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "61", "TotalMoves-2nd": "56", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-185404", "UUID": "019056be-76b4-7379-8e71-e9519513891e" }, { "GameType": "gomoku", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "1", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "5", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "38", "TotalMoves-2nd": "38", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-185530", "UUID": "019056c1-90bc-7136-94e4-859ab63add07" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.05714285714285714", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.11428571428571428", "TotalMoves-1st": "35", "TotalMoves-2nd": "35", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-102413", "UUID": "01903607-cd94-709b-aed1-8260c8057465" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.04878048780487805", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.14285714285714285", "TotalMoves-1st": "41", "TotalMoves-2nd": "42", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-102529", "UUID": "01903608-a20b-7808-a10f-5cc3edfb473a" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.023255813953488372", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.04878048780487805", "TotalMoves-1st": "43", "TotalMoves-2nd": "41", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-102638", "UUID": "01903609-ca2a-71c5-bc35-48056da23da0" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.05263157894736842", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.13559322033898305", "TotalMoves-1st": "57", "TotalMoves-2nd": "59", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-102751", "UUID": "0190360a-d5a4-7018-bc5b-873fd37e2c1b" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.05084745762711865", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.01818181818181818", "TotalMoves-1st": "59", "TotalMoves-2nd": "55", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-102911", "UUID": "0190360b-f60f-74a5-b8e5-797f73f40771" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "45", "TotalMoves-2nd": "44", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-103031", "UUID": "0190360d-2e19-7a72-b363-d8a08640d71d" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.05555555555555555", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.06451612903225806", "TotalMoves-1st": "36", "TotalMoves-2nd": "31", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-073349", "UUID": "0190356b-d178-765b-9dd6-9043c9c5b22e" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.05714285714285714", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.03333333333333333", "TotalMoves-1st": "35", "TotalMoves-2nd": "30", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-073455", "UUID": "0190356c-9f5f-7034-b0bd-eb861785c3e0" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.04878048780487805", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "41", "TotalMoves-2nd": "35", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-073607", "UUID": "0190356d-a22c-730a-b34b-3c9444832980" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "30", "TotalMoves-2nd": "25", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-073705", "UUID": "0190356e-bbc3-72cf-bd48-a64c3ea19477" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "29", "TotalMoves-2nd": "25", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-073800", "UUID": "0190356f-9d64-7246-9d69-2b1130202512" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.02127659574468085", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.022727272727272728", "TotalMoves-1st": "47", "TotalMoves-2nd": "44", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-073923", "UUID": "01903570-740f-7f56-8aeb-b7bef2e699e8" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.25", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3939393939393939", "TotalMoves-1st": "56", "TotalMoves-2nd": "66", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-192529", "UUID": "01900ec2-8f97-7c80-a855-62a0f01d87a9" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2463768115942029", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.14545454545454545", "TotalMoves-1st": "69", "TotalMoves-2nd": "55", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-192833", "UUID": "01900ec5-4aa9-70db-8e3a-6cf16f0086bc" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.13157894736842105", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "38", "TotalMoves-2nd": "29", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-193021", "UUID": "01900ec8-19f8-7c54-9b3d-f5542180dd2c" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "25", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-193145", "UUID": "01900ec9-bf55-7d64-a366-4727cd02bf44" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.16071428571428573", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "56", "TotalMoves-2nd": "43", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-193424", "UUID": "01900ecb-09c0-7930-8040-c74f399d71c4" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.32786885245901637", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.2549019607843137", "TotalMoves-1st": "61", "TotalMoves-2nd": "51", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-193713", "UUID": "01900ecd-7742-7054-9011-5df1c007123a" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.24074074074074073", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.22916666666666666", "TotalMoves-1st": "54", "TotalMoves-2nd": "48", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-194006", "UUID": "01900ed0-0b51-7c84-9404-00597eca77a6" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.21568627450980393", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "51", "TotalMoves-2nd": "36", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-194233", "UUID": "01900ed2-adb0-7041-8478-4dc61b8eded8" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "26", "TotalMoves-2nd": "21", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-195115", "UUID": "01900ed4-ea9f-7ad0-bf62-513552559f43" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.19607843137254902", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.02631578947368421", "TotalMoves-1st": "51", "TotalMoves-2nd": "38", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-195353", "UUID": "01900edc-e3d0-7d2c-8a71-0b98f7bcd2c9" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.22641509433962265", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.28", "TotalMoves-1st": "53", "TotalMoves-2nd": "50", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-195629", "UUID": "01900edf-4c0d-7729-800e-a35366b6c17e" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.21818181818181817", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.38461538461538464", "TotalMoves-1st": "55", "TotalMoves-2nd": "65", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-195953", "UUID": "01900ee1-abf0-765b-8996-09b3b7fe38ff" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "25", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-200118", "UUID": "01900ee4-caf2-7514-907d-44e1118e9837" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "25", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-200248", "UUID": "01900ee6-177b-7a1a-a6f8-d4a62ddaa8d6" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "30", "TotalMoves-2nd": "25", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-200439", "UUID": "01900ee7-7795-7c75-8769-635075bce4f7" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "1", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "5", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-200555", "UUID": "01900ee9-2912-71bf-baf9-331491cf6345" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "24", "TotalMoves-2nd": "21", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-200723", "UUID": "01900eea-5135-79dc-b443-75ea3238872b" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-200836", "UUID": "01900eeb-a6a6-7c5d-943c-495d5ebbb735" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-200948", "UUID": "01900eec-c3b1-70ff-8349-058cf9206c60" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "26", "TotalMoves-2nd": "22", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-201119", "UUID": "01900eed-de3b-76e5-ab22-c205915cc64d" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-201229", "UUID": "01900eef-4394-7379-b76f-33b569e6be68" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-201342", "UUID": "01900ef0-5261-73a2-b054-2e8d91b8dd2a" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "28", "TotalMoves-2nd": "25", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-201520", "UUID": "01900ef1-7226-73a9-8e23-8871ae7301cc" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-201630", "UUID": "01900ef2-f00e-718d-b32e-e45ede9aa915" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.020833333333333332", "TotalMoves-1st": "49", "TotalMoves-2nd": "48", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-201913", "UUID": "01900ef4-0222-71b7-b507-34d1761feefb" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.06060606060606061", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.15151515151515152", "TotalMoves-1st": "33", "TotalMoves-2nd": "33", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-202104", "UUID": "01900ef6-7e2f-7075-a1b8-507b98f9ed7b" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.06976744186046512", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.0975609756097561", "TotalMoves-1st": "43", "TotalMoves-2nd": "41", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-202337", "UUID": "01900ef8-30c9-7f61-b420-89915326cc47" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.023255813953488372", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.0975609756097561", "TotalMoves-1st": "43", "TotalMoves-2nd": "41", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-202611", "UUID": "01900efa-84ff-73f6-aeec-bc1c5c925343" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "51", "TotalMoves-2nd": "49", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-202904", "UUID": "01900efc-e019-70e0-9ca8-d68819a1e30a" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "38", "TotalMoves-2nd": "35", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240612-203105", "UUID": "01900eff-819b-7b20-a4b2-d21d774aa0f0" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.20930232558139536", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.14705882352941177", "TotalMoves-1st": "43", "TotalMoves-2nd": "34", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-225101", "UUID": "01905272-facf-768e-a1e1-28ac7729292d" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3090909090909091", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.21428571428571427", "TotalMoves-1st": "55", "TotalMoves-2nd": "42", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-225243", "UUID": "01905274-2306-7433-b2b7-0376f503d60c" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2857142857142857", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.05263157894736842", "TotalMoves-1st": "77", "TotalMoves-2nd": "57", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-225520", "UUID": "01905275-b41d-7b60-8038-20a1c7cce1c7" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.14285714285714285", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "35", "TotalMoves-2nd": "25", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-225623", "UUID": "01905278-174c-7036-92e1-bcfc889e801e" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "25", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-225706", "UUID": "01905279-0c2e-7566-8466-857082529264" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2549019607843137", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "51", "TotalMoves-2nd": "33", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-225838", "UUID": "01905279-b6f3-7709-b322-a2e2a235452b" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.1111111111111111", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.05", "TotalMoves-1st": "27", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-225910", "UUID": "0190527b-1c11-7b7a-a21e-d950c00e21ba" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.21428571428571427", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.25925925925925924", "TotalMoves-1st": "56", "TotalMoves-2nd": "54", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-230059", "UUID": "0190527b-9b71-7aad-852f-d51f4a785198" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.45121951219512196", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.23214285714285715", "TotalMoves-1st": "82", "TotalMoves-2nd": "56", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-230327", "UUID": "0190527d-43e8-7a11-9bdc-6e045b01971b" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.22388059701492538", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3472222222222222", "TotalMoves-1st": "67", "TotalMoves-2nd": "72", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-230605", "UUID": "0190527f-84e3-78a6-9c0e-25e18a786f39" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "21", "TotalMoves-2nd": "16", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-230641", "UUID": "01905281-f06f-7ca7-ad50-b6c7120dff53" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "20", "TotalMoves-2nd": "15", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-230712", "UUID": "01905282-7b9f-7051-98a4-be10a8e49cd9" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.15384615384615385", "TotalMoves-1st": "36", "TotalMoves-2nd": "39", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-230839", "UUID": "01905282-f3a2-7339-8de3-3b4ae541c700" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "list", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.16923076923076924", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.07142857142857142", "TotalMoves-1st": "65", "TotalMoves-2nd": "56", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-231005", "UUID": "01905284-47a7-7593-a83d-e5032a14cdc2" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.02040816326530612", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.02127659574468085", "TotalMoves-1st": "49", "TotalMoves-2nd": "47", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-104023", "UUID": "01903615-721e-7488-8e4e-a9883b7a9859" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "1", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "5", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "26", "TotalMoves-2nd": "26", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-104151", "UUID": "01903617-6e28-79c9-9aeb-979ac0ab4395" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.1951219512195122", "TotalMoves-1st": "34", "TotalMoves-2nd": "41", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-104328", "UUID": "01903618-c582-7b8c-8039-323508e934a1" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.10810810810810811", "TotalMoves-1st": "35", "TotalMoves-2nd": "37", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-104451", "UUID": "0190361a-402f-7e3f-92e2-625b5e9183da" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.0625", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.21621621621621623", "TotalMoves-1st": "32", "TotalMoves-2nd": "37", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-104619", "UUID": "0190361b-83cb-70a5-b2f1-28792e6ca8b8" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.022222222222222223", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "45", "TotalMoves-2nd": "40", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-074146", "UUID": "01903572-0468-72e4-81a7-fdb8a570fa08" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2391304347826087", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.06060606060606061", "TotalMoves-1st": "46", "TotalMoves-2nd": "33", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-074356", "UUID": "01903573-e781-75ca-8d67-06878496f327" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.16666666666666666", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.10416666666666667", "TotalMoves-1st": "54", "TotalMoves-2nd": "48", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-074556", "UUID": "01903575-e1bb-7837-9487-3c9d670ee249" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2222222222222222", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "45", "TotalMoves-2nd": "31", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-074730", "UUID": "01903577-b703-7e25-9936-f24af358dc7c" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.22857142857142856", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "35", "TotalMoves-2nd": "23", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-074852", "UUID": "01903579-26b8-7238-99e7-f562652cf51d" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.25", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3235294117647059", "TotalMoves-1st": "64", "TotalMoves-2nd": "68", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-114549", "UUID": "01901241-0412-7b61-8e34-19f44812de3b" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2923076923076923", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.34375", "TotalMoves-1st": "65", "TotalMoves-2nd": "64", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-115100", "UUID": "01901246-d180-7f92-85e2-02dc6c51df6b" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.10256410256410256", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.21052631578947367", "TotalMoves-1st": "39", "TotalMoves-2nd": "38", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-115416", "UUID": "0190124b-90de-7e71-9038-f1dc1e4f68bc" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "3", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.22413793103448276", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.36923076923076925", "TotalMoves-1st": "58", "TotalMoves-2nd": "65", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-115849", "UUID": "0190124e-8e69-79f2-af96-03317deff208" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3888888888888889", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3181818181818182", "TotalMoves-1st": "54", "TotalMoves-2nd": "44", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-120620", "UUID": "01901252-b716-7b0a-9f04-28c4541b057b" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.36363636363636365", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3404255319148936", "TotalMoves-1st": "55", "TotalMoves-2nd": "47", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-121000", "UUID": "01901259-9a7b-77c1-9f50-7ab5277cebc5" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.32142857142857145", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3137254901960784", "TotalMoves-1st": "56", "TotalMoves-2nd": "51", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-121410", "UUID": "0190125c-f5f8-7c9c-98fa-bdd71c4a0861" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.43243243243243246", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3387096774193548", "TotalMoves-1st": "74", "TotalMoves-2nd": "62", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-121911", "UUID": "01901260-c6ea-7050-8e1f-afe2e5536964" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3333333333333333", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.1724137931034483", "TotalMoves-1st": "75", "TotalMoves-2nd": "58", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-122424", "UUID": "01901265-5f0b-7adc-85eb-a9a2f4320ad7" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3287671232876712", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.323943661971831", "TotalMoves-1st": "73", "TotalMoves-2nd": "71", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-122941", "UUID": "0190126a-245b-77f8-9e18-b1611b4ce16d" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.20512820512820512", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.12903225806451613", "TotalMoves-1st": "39", "TotalMoves-2nd": "31", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-123152", "UUID": "0190126e-f91e-7561-9b2a-3c0415ea3b3f" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.48148148148148145", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3787878787878788", "TotalMoves-1st": "81", "TotalMoves-2nd": "66", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-123612", "UUID": "01901270-f9e5-703a-832f-5bd2e3a08683" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4520547945205479", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.2777777777777778", "TotalMoves-1st": "73", "TotalMoves-2nd": "54", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-124054", "UUID": "01901274-f1a4-7b8d-97e2-3498224357f5" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3148148148148148", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3333333333333333", "TotalMoves-1st": "54", "TotalMoves-2nd": "48", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-132913", "UUID": "01901279-3ed5-7add-8404-80c3389bc8f8" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5384615384615384", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.2564102564102564", "TotalMoves-1st": "65", "TotalMoves-2nd": "39", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-133205", "UUID": "019012a5-7a99-77f6-8ff4-a35cc2727b76" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4931506849315068", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4", "TotalMoves-1st": "73", "TotalMoves-2nd": "60", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-133611", "UUID": "019012a8-1bcc-718a-bd3c-02bb0846eb54" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.45569620253164556", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.39705882352941174", "TotalMoves-1st": "79", "TotalMoves-2nd": "68", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-134159", "UUID": "019012ab-dc64-7a7a-824e-ee8e6ca4509c" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.42857142857142855", "TotalMoves-1st": "65", "TotalMoves-2nd": "63", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-134652", "UUID": "019012b1-2a97-7128-ae21-898b2bdecd9a" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.48484848484848486", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.38461538461538464", "TotalMoves-1st": "66", "TotalMoves-2nd": "52", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-135018", "UUID": "019012b5-a4bd-7a9b-8c95-1bfe922f40a0" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "3", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4444444444444444", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5076923076923077", "TotalMoves-1st": "63", "TotalMoves-2nd": "65", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240613-135351", "UUID": "019012b8-c7f7-74ac-8027-55cd209cccb1" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3380281690140845", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.2833333333333333", "TotalMoves-1st": "71", "TotalMoves-2nd": "60", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-233640", "UUID": "0190529a-e734-7510-8223-b43a7064a850" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.23214285714285715", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3870967741935484", "TotalMoves-1st": "56", "TotalMoves-2nd": "62", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-233947", "UUID": "0190529d-ed5b-738a-8b0a-48fe994967e5" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.36363636363636365", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4482758620689655", "TotalMoves-1st": "55", "TotalMoves-2nd": "58", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-234209", "UUID": "019052a0-cb9d-7e62-b4c9-51dad4c8228b" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.48484848484848486", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4576271186440678", "TotalMoves-1st": "66", "TotalMoves-2nd": "59", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-234434", "UUID": "019052a2-f3f6-79d7-bb39-21c12654bac3" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3787878787878788", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3870967741935484", "TotalMoves-1st": "66", "TotalMoves-2nd": "62", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-234716", "UUID": "019052a5-2bb2-75ec-ba33-717eb2a8e0cc" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.11904761904761904", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.1111111111111111", "TotalMoves-1st": "42", "TotalMoves-2nd": "36", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-234819", "UUID": "019052a7-a277-76ee-a89b-a5c6f5092c93" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.21875", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.07407407407407407", "TotalMoves-1st": "64", "TotalMoves-2nd": "54", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-235116", "UUID": "019052a8-9c4e-7765-a9b0-82a6b767cb8a" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3829787234042553", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.15151515151515152", "TotalMoves-1st": "47", "TotalMoves-2nd": "33", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-235321", "UUID": "019052ab-4cab-7de6-8c56-d859674b7729" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.35365853658536583", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.16129032258064516", "TotalMoves-1st": "82", "TotalMoves-2nd": "62", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-235644", "UUID": "019052ad-3496-75ca-977e-610c22bf7224" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3548387096774194", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.21739130434782608", "TotalMoves-1st": "62", "TotalMoves-2nd": "46", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-235851", "UUID": "019052b0-4da3-7f87-8187-ee6dd98df163" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.453125", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.13157894736842105", "TotalMoves-1st": "64", "TotalMoves-2nd": "38", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-000059", "UUID": "019052b2-3d3c-72f6-a6ff-f8af25a9ed5a" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "image", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.043478260869565216", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.023255813953488372", "TotalMoves-1st": "46", "TotalMoves-2nd": "43", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240626-000209", "UUID": "019052b4-3422-7c51-a8ce-7410b51e4ea0" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "40", "TotalMoves-2nd": "38", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-103159", "UUID": "0190360e-d15d-7ecf-84d4-bb0f55d26d4b" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.16129032258064516", "TotalMoves-1st": "28", "TotalMoves-2nd": "31", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-103302", "UUID": "0190360f-bc01-7f16-b40b-d4bc66049d29" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "24", "TotalMoves-2nd": "23", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-103353", "UUID": "01903610-b3a9-75a3-a8e3-2cc6a9940439" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "45", "TotalMoves-2nd": "44", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-103500", "UUID": "01903611-797d-796c-9fb2-b3362b55f303" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.04081632653061224", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.20689655172413793", "TotalMoves-1st": "49", "TotalMoves-2nd": "58", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-103615", "UUID": "01903612-81ea-7931-8265-1fc2deb2d536" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.05128205128205128", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.05263157894736842", "TotalMoves-1st": "39", "TotalMoves-2nd": "38", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-103725", "UUID": "01903613-a6af-792d-bdf6-08dd4d66c467" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.1", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "40", "TotalMoves-2nd": "32", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-081002", "UUID": "0190358c-dc49-7878-94cc-14ecb63603e9" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3404255319148936", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.034482758620689655", "TotalMoves-1st": "47", "TotalMoves-2nd": "29", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-081120", "UUID": "0190358d-c609-7739-8b6c-34c2a7ff46a3" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.1320754716981132", "TotalMoves-1st": "70", "TotalMoves-2nd": "53", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-081312", "UUID": "0190358e-f797-7588-b194-b11526ed44e7" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "24", "TotalMoves-2nd": "19", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-081401", "UUID": "01903590-aeb6-7fd9-8850-85603116c162" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.034482758620689655", "TotalMoves-1st": "40", "TotalMoves-2nd": "29", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-081502", "UUID": "01903591-6cdc-712f-be6e-681e148a61f7" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.06666666666666667", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.041666666666666664", "TotalMoves-1st": "30", "TotalMoves-2nd": "24", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240620-081605", "UUID": "01903592-5cd9-7268-9fcb-8ea8ebb945ba" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6290322580645161", "TotalMoves-1st": "35", "TotalMoves-2nd": "62", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-065222", "UUID": "0190165e-7a40-7c6b-9ec5-243fafc8c185" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.22580645161290322", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.35714285714285715", "TotalMoves-1st": "62", "TotalMoves-2nd": "70", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-065510", "UUID": "01901660-83a6-7097-b545-6bdfff405b4f" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.20408163265306123", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.2391304347826087", "TotalMoves-1st": "49", "TotalMoves-2nd": "46", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-065718", "UUID": "01901663-1656-7b3c-b52e-56b309f42613" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.14285714285714285", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.19607843137254902", "TotalMoves-1st": "49", "TotalMoves-2nd": "51", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-065942", "UUID": "01901665-0a53-73ea-9b6c-db61e14d43ed" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.22857142857142856", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3333333333333333", "TotalMoves-1st": "70", "TotalMoves-2nd": "75", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-070304", "UUID": "01901667-3bdc-78f4-906d-f50715401352" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "5", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.6060606060606061", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.13333333333333333", "TotalMoves-1st": "66", "TotalMoves-2nd": "30", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-070553", "UUID": "0190166a-4f80-7cc3-84fb-d9e0b68301bb" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "5", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.6451612903225806", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.2413793103448276", "TotalMoves-1st": "62", "TotalMoves-2nd": "29", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-070847", "UUID": "0190166c-e5ff-7741-bf75-877d0197c2b8" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.6129032258064516", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.041666666666666664", "TotalMoves-1st": "62", "TotalMoves-2nd": "24", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-071103", "UUID": "0190166f-8cf4-7df2-a9a4-b37b07fe6c55" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "5", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.6779661016949152", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.05", "TotalMoves-1st": "59", "TotalMoves-2nd": "20", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-071306", "UUID": "01901671-9f92-7804-8cf0-958b9d8a62e3" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.546875", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.125", "TotalMoves-1st": "64", "TotalMoves-2nd": "32", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-071532", "UUID": "01901673-81a6-7fb4-b6f9-9f55fae1a8e1" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.35294117647058826", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.26785714285714285", "TotalMoves-1st": "68", "TotalMoves-2nd": "56", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-071817", "UUID": "01901675-ba0a-7c5c-9ab9-a0494cdc37b2" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "4", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.32558139534883723", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6031746031746031", "TotalMoves-1st": "43", "TotalMoves-2nd": "63", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-072108", "UUID": "01901678-4055-7558-91fa-5d700fa4c2df" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.8", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "4", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.35", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.22448979591836735", "TotalMoves-1st": "60", "TotalMoves-2nd": "49", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-072356", "UUID": "0190167a-dc1d-77ba-bd74-68526b9e91a7" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "3", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.2619047619047619", "TotalMoves-1st": "64", "TotalMoves-2nd": "42", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-072645", "UUID": "0190167d-6981-79ec-89b8-23dc2bc0843d" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3291139240506329", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.2537313432835821", "TotalMoves-1st": "79", "TotalMoves-2nd": "67", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-073445", "UUID": "01901680-00d8-7105-a38f-9c405becbe00" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.18867924528301888", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.25", "TotalMoves-1st": "53", "TotalMoves-2nd": "52", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-073653", "UUID": "01901687-52b8-7925-82cb-14158665f644" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "3", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.03333333333333333", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.5932203389830508", "TotalMoves-1st": "30", "TotalMoves-2nd": "59", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-073914", "UUID": "01901689-4581-7ccd-9377-1e1b413f1da4" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.07317073170731707", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.23255813953488372", "TotalMoves-1st": "41", "TotalMoves-2nd": "43", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-074126", "UUID": "0190168b-6d39-779a-96f0-8bd1ca018f1b" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.0975609756097561", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.20930232558139536", "TotalMoves-1st": "41", "TotalMoves-2nd": "43", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-074315", "UUID": "0190168d-6e9c-712d-aebe-d0fa8251c89a" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.11904761904761904", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.07894736842105263", "TotalMoves-1st": "42", "TotalMoves-2nd": "38", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-074515", "UUID": "0190168f-1ba8-7f2f-8d9c-c2d613d756d1" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.32894736842105265", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.2", "TotalMoves-1st": "76", "TotalMoves-2nd": "60", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-074829", "UUID": "01901690-ed66-774b-aca3-ea5ebde500ac" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "5", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2894736842105263", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6451612903225806", "TotalMoves-1st": "38", "TotalMoves-2nd": "62", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-075115", "UUID": "01901693-e448-793a-aecf-ad4833c02518" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3880597014925373", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4788732394366197", "TotalMoves-1st": "67", "TotalMoves-2nd": "71", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-075508", "UUID": "01901696-6daf-7dab-bb37-ace53c5892c7" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.25", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.24444444444444444", "TotalMoves-1st": "48", "TotalMoves-2nd": "45", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-075710", "UUID": "01901699-f9d5-7b86-85f2-fb802718a47a" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3076923076923077", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.2222222222222222", "TotalMoves-1st": "65", "TotalMoves-2nd": "54", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-080625", "UUID": "0190169b-d7f2-7142-a8ac-c2affcca0cb9" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.36904761904761907", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.1935483870967742", "TotalMoves-1st": "84", "TotalMoves-2nd": "62", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-080942", "UUID": "019016a4-4e53-7760-99bf-82b7f3da5f0a" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "5", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2857142857142857", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.6153846153846154", "TotalMoves-1st": "42", "TotalMoves-2nd": "65", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-081243", "UUID": "019016a7-5097-7ccf-bbe1-1e6060800b1b" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.34328358208955223", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.4533333333333333", "TotalMoves-1st": "67", "TotalMoves-2nd": "75", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-081633", "UUID": "019016aa-147c-7b05-86b1-70a17e1d598b" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.37142857142857144", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.27586206896551724", "TotalMoves-1st": "70", "TotalMoves-2nd": "58", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-082007", "UUID": "019016ad-97b7-747f-b768-41708358f52d" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3787878787878788", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.23529411764705882", "TotalMoves-1st": "66", "TotalMoves-2nd": "51", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240614-082307", "UUID": "019016b0-d995-76a4-934f-6d20939b2da1" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4o", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.345679012345679", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.20634920634920634", "TotalMoves-1st": "81", "TotalMoves-2nd": "63", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-231232", "UUID": "01905285-9714-7f98-ba7b-eb38b1ace477" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "3", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.10344827586206896", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.56", "TotalMoves-1st": "29", "TotalMoves-2nd": "50", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-231353", "UUID": "01905287-d7d5-7e0f-a04f-282ab75a9e6a" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.1956521739130435", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.38181818181818183", "TotalMoves-1st": "46", "TotalMoves-2nd": "55", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-231545", "UUID": "01905289-1374-7674-a9eb-fc8b6b40bc8a" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3050847457627119", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.15555555555555556", "TotalMoves-1st": "59", "TotalMoves-2nd": "45", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-231732", "UUID": "0190528a-cabf-7485-a8be-58745837a6ba" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.0625", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.06896551724137931", "TotalMoves-1st": "32", "TotalMoves-2nd": "29", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-231828", "UUID": "0190528c-6b18-7257-8c2d-60d6a803c3f8" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.6", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "3", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.21428571428571427", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.11764705882352941", "TotalMoves-1st": "42", "TotalMoves-2nd": "34", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-231948", "UUID": "0190528d-46f0-77e7-b71b-fa1822769083" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "random-play", "WinRatio-1st": "1", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "5", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.03225806451612903", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0", "TotalMoves-1st": "31", "TotalMoves-2nd": "25", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-232028", "UUID": "0190528e-7f45-7e17-af7c-edc72a7683f4" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4o", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "0", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "3", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.3103448275862069", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.47058823529411764", "TotalMoves-1st": "58", "TotalMoves-2nd": "68", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-232231", "UUID": "0190528f-1c53-7fb2-825d-94dd4835c096" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gpt-4-turbo", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "4", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.5588235294117647", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.23076923076923078", "TotalMoves-1st": "68", "TotalMoves-2nd": "39", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-232419", "UUID": "01905290-faf1-7db6-9e47-969ee3ab73e0" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-pro", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.8", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "4", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.10810810810810811", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.06451612903225806", "TotalMoves-1st": "37", "TotalMoves-2nd": "31", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-232535", "UUID": "01905292-a10c-7351-9b52-f83350936b1b" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "gemini-1.5-flash", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.18", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.32142857142857145", "TotalMoves-1st": "50", "TotalMoves-2nd": "56", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-232720", "UUID": "01905293-ca4f-7b1f-8e71-ac07acea838d" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "meta.llama3-70b-instruct-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.2", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.2", "Wins-1st": "1", "Wins-2nd": "1", "Disqualifications-1st": "1", "Disqualifications-2nd": "2", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.2631578947368421", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.417910447761194", "TotalMoves-1st": "57", "TotalMoves-2nd": "67", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-232919", "UUID": "01905295-64d6-78d9-86a8-ea0c8c58d501" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-sonnet-20240229-v1:0", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.4", "Wins-1st": "0", "Wins-2nd": "2", "Disqualifications-1st": "2", "Disqualifications-2nd": "1", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0.4069767441860465", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.3333333333333333", "TotalMoves-1st": "86", "TotalMoves-2nd": "75", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-233208", "UUID": "01905297-35ae-70dc-ae83-db892da5392e" }, { "GameType": "connect-four", "PromptType": "illustration", "PromptVersion": "2024-06-12", "LLM1stPlayer": "random-play", "LLM2ndPlayer": "anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620-v1:0", "WinRatio-1st": "0.4", "WinRatio-2nd": "0.6", "Wins-1st": "2", "Wins-2nd": "3", "Disqualifications-1st": "0", "Disqualifications-2nd": "0", "Draws": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-1st": "0", "InvalidMovesRatio-2nd": "0.1", "TotalMoves-1st": "47", "TotalMoves-2nd": "50", "ProviderEmail": "otopsakal@floridapoly.edu", "DateTime": "240625-233321", "UUID": "01905299-c868-758e-999c-033f8e24d8e7" } ]